Brendan’s Alternate Tagline for Strangers in the Land:
It didn’t get better once the railroads were finished.
Quick synopsis:
The story of Chinese immigrants who came to America.
Fun Fact Non-History People Will Like:
It took seven weeks for news of the death of President Zachary Taylor to reach California.
Fun Fact for History Nerds:
Chinese workers were at one point estimated to take less than 28 minutes to lay a half mile of railroad tracks.
My Take on Strangers in the Land:
I’m not sure I have ever written a review like this one but here it goes. Michael Luo’s Strangers in the Land is an exceptional book with impeccable research, riveting stories, and important historical lessons. There is a bit too much of it, though. Let me explain!
Luo tells the story of the Chinese in America. I think most people remember grade school where the atrocious treatment of Chinese immigrants on the West Coast when they were integral in the completion of the transcontinental railroad. Luo takes it a step further to chronicle specific stories of these immigrants whether it is about the laundry they opened or a horrific mob attack. I don’t want to understate how much work Luo put into this and how effectively he tells these stories. Often, people exist only in a smattering of records, but the author is able to piece together a story which will move the reader. I will explain my criticism, but I don’t want it to take away from the excellent work Luo has done.
The issue is such a weird one to explain. I mean chocolate is great but what’s better? More chocolate! However, Luo just puts too much into this book. The exceptional stories I mentioned are overwhelming and while the first half of the book was engaging, it starts to drag after the midway point. The issue is that those small stories start to pass by and blend with similar stories you already read about. There are certain chapters which cover a topic that makes it distinct, but there are others which seem to cover much of the same material but in a different city. Luo also focused the vast majority of the book in the 1800s. The last couple of chapters then cover 60 years in a flash. The pace is off just enough to be noticeable but not fatal.
My criticism aside, this is definitely a book worth reading with an important story that is told well, overall.
(This book was provided as an advance copy by Netgalley and Doubleday Books.)
Verdict:
Not perfect, but still a must read. Buy it here!
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.