Brendan’s Alternate Tagline for Second Life:
As if parenting weren’t anxiety inducing already.
Quick synopsis:
A memoir of parenting in the digital age.
Fact for Non-History People:
In 1900, only 5% of childbirths took place in hospitals.
Fact for History Nerds:
By 2020, 98.3% of childbirths took place in hospitals.
My Take on Second Life:
It is only fair that before I start critiquing a book on pregnancy and birth that I come clean. I know and admit full well that I would be terrible at having a baby. I would whine, complain, and you’d need to drug me up so much to get through the whole thing. In summary, if you need me to admit that the author, Amanda Hess, is tougher than me then no problem! She is. As the father of a daughter, I have other, less impressive skills like reaching the top shelf, hanging things, and sarcasm. I am okay with my lot in life.
Hess has written Second Life which is a chronicle of the birth of her first son and all the technology and social media around this momentous life change. I find with memoirs I need the author to establish early on that they know writing a memoir is an exercise in navel gazing. I connect best with authors who admit their own failings and don’t take themselves too seriously. Life is not easy, and pretty all the time and an idealized main character is an absolute bore. Luckily, Hess knows this and never misses a chance to let the reader know how she can be anxious, hyper critical, and hypocritical. My favorite example was her willingness to look back on an article she had read years ago about not having children and detailing just how badly it has aged. It doesn’t make her look bad because who doesn’t have something in their past they really wish they could forget?
The strongest sections are when Hess focuses on specific things which touch on her own experiences. The first chapter revolves around a health app called Flo (if you can’t guess what it focuses on then head back to health class). Hess breaks down how this app burrowed into her psyche and at times made the process of getting pregnant and being pregnant feel like just another online activity. She also dives into other parenting trends like “freebirthing” with similar incisiveness.
My sole criticism is with sections where Hess tries to comment on wider issues related to scenarios outside her specific experience. For example, she introduces studies about the higher rate of c-sections among Black women in the U.S. Examples like this need much deeper analysis than what she gives and it wouldn’t fit in the book stylistically if she did explore deeper. These sections are not numerous so don’t let this critique deter you from reading it.
I might as well be blunt (something new for me!). I do not think this book will be very entertaining for people who don’t want or have kids. That’s not a failure on Hess’s part, but merely my observation on the subject matter. Hess’s point of view is obviously from her perspective as a mother, but I still found a lot to like as a dad reading it. However, anyone uninterested in parenting will not find enough to keep them interested in my opinion.
(This book was provided as an advance copy by NetGalley and Doubleday Books.)
Verdict:
A great read for parents. Buy it here!
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.